Final Position: 1st – Portsmouth
Home Fixture: 19/09/2023 Barnsley (Barry Cotter 49, Callum Styles 77) 2-3 Portsmouth (Paddy Lane 8, Colby Bishop pen 8, Connor Ogilvie 16)
Away Fixture: 16/04/2024 Portsmouth (Kusini Yengi 9, Colby Bishop pen 83, Conor Saughnessy 89) 3-2 Barnsley (Devante Cole 6, John McAtee 59)
Aggregate Score 4-6
Final Position: 2nd – Derby County
Away Fixture: 11/11/2023 Derby (James Collins pen 35, 63, Craig Forsyth 48) 3-0 Barnsley
Home Fixture: 24/02/2024 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 33, 66) 2-1 Derby (Sonny Bradley 18)
Aggregate Score 2-4
Final Position: 3rd – Bolton Wanderers
Away Fixture: 03/02/2024 Bolton (Zac Ashworth 64) 1-1 Barnsley (Devante Cole 5)
Home Fixture: 05/03/2024 Barnsley (John McAtee 25, Donovan Pines 47) 2-2 Bolton (Victor Adeboyejo 62, Randell Williams 90)
Aggregate Score 3-3
Final Position: 4th – Peterborough United
Home Fixture: 15/08/2023 Barnsley (Barry Cotter 51) 1-3 Peterborough (Hector Kyprianou 74, Jonson Clarke-Harris 76, Kwame Poku 85)
Away Fixture: 29/12/2023 Peterborough (Jonson Clarke-Harris 45, 48) 2-2 Barnsley (Herbie Kane 10, Devante Cole 31)
Aggregate Score 3-5
Final Position: 5th – Oxford United
Home Fixture: 19/08/2023 Barnsley (Devante Cole 70) 1-3 Oxford (Cameron Brannagan pen 8, Jordan Williams og 54, Tyler Goodrham 88)
Away Fixture: 23/01/2024 Oxford 0-1 Barnsley (Sam Long og 29)
Aggregate Score 2-3
Final Position: 7th – Lincoln City
Away Fixture: 25/11/2023 Lincoln (Daniel Mandroiu pen 5, Timothy Eyoma 88) 2-2 Barnsley (Barry Cotter 68, John McAtee 72)
Home Fixture: 09/03/2024 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 77) 1-5 Lincoln (Joseph Taylor 15, Jack Moylan 55, 72, Daniel Mandroiu 58, Jovon Makama 79)
Aggregate Score 3-7
Final Position: 8th - Blackpool
Home Fixture: 30/09/2023 Barnsley 0-1 Blackpool (Jordan Rhodes pen 24)
Away Fixture: 20/04/2024 Blackpool (Sonny Carey 12, James Husband 45, Hayden Coulson 47) 3-2 Barnsley (John McAtee 67, Adam Phillips 90)
Aggregate Score 2-4
Final Position: 9th – Stevenage
Home Fixture: 23/12/2023 Barnsley (John McAtee 32, Herbie Kane 70) 2-1 Stevenage (Luther Wildin 4)
Away Fixture: 09/04/2024 Stevenage (Jamie Reid 45, Dan Butler 51) 2-1 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 30)
Aggregate Score 3-3
Final Position: 10th – Wycombe Wanderers
Home Fixture: 28/11/2023 Barnsley (Sam Cosgrove 90) 1-0 Wycombe
Away Fixture: 02/03/2024 Wycombe (Dale Taylor 16, Kieran Sadlier 52) 2-4 Barnsley (Sam Cosgrove 45, Donovan Pines 56, Corey O’Keeffe 65, Conor Grant 72
Aggregate Score 5-2
Final Position: 11th – Leyton Orient
Away Fixture: 21/10/2023 Leyton Orient (Joe Pigott pen 27) 1-1Barnsley (Herbie Kane 69)
Home Fixture: 10/02/2024 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 88, 90) 2-1 Leyton Orient (Ruel Sotiriou 10)
Aggregate Score 3-2
Final Position: 12th – Wigan Athletic
Away Fixture: 26/08/2023 Wigan 0-2 Barnsley (Devante Cole 25, John McAtee 90)
Home Fixture: 01/01/2024 Barnsley (Devante Cole 45)1-1 Wigan (Jonny Smith 87)
Aggregate Score 3-1
Overall record v top half: W7 D6 L9 F33 A40 Points: 27
Final Position: 13th – Exeter City
Away Fixture: 07/10/2023 Exeter 0-1 Barnsley (John McAtee 89)
Home Fixture: 27/01/2024 Barnsley (Mael de Gevigney 87) 1-2 Exeter (Jack Aitchison 17, Reece Cole 30)
Aggregate Score 2-2
Final Position: 14th – Northampton Town
Away Fixture: 23/09/2023 Northampton (Louis Appere 90) 1-2 Barnsley (Callum Styles 4, Devante Cole 88)
Home Fixture: 27/04/2024 Barnsley (Herbie Kane 18) 1-1 Northampton (Louis Appere 90)
Aggregate Score 3-2
Final Position: 15th – Bristol Rovers
Away Fixture: 12/08/2023 Bristol Rovers (Scott Sinclair 81) 1-1 Barnsley (Nicky Cadden 7)
Home Fixture: 13/01/2024 Barnsley (Devante Cole 43, Corey O’Keeffe 73) 2-1 Bristol Rovers (Chris Martin 68)
Aggregate Score 3-2
Final Position: 16th – Charlton Athletic
Home Fixture: 16/12/2023 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 24) 1-1 Charlton (Corey Blackett-Taylor 70)
Away Fixture: 06/04/2024 Charlton (Alfie May 20, 40) 2-1 Barnsley (Adam Phillips pen 28)
Aggregate Score 2-3
Final Position: 17th – Reading
Away Fixture: 09/12/2023 Reading (Harvey Knibbs 4) 1-3 Barnsley (Herbie Kane pen 39, Devante Cole 80, Max Watters 87)
Home Fixture: 13/04/2024 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 29, Fabio Jalo 83) 2-2 Reading (Sam Smith 21, Lewis Wing 81)
Aggregate Score 5-3
Final Position: 18th – Cambridge United
Away Fixture: 03/10/2023 Cambridge 0-4 Barnsley (Nicky Cadden 7, Mael de Gevigney 33, Max Watters 59, Jon Russell 83)
Home Fixture: 29/03/2024 Barnsley 0-2 Cambridge (Mael de Gevigney og 13, Gassan Ahadme 72)
Aggregate Score 4-2
Final Position: 19th – Shrewsbury Town
Home Fixture: 24/10/2023 Barnsley (Herbie Kane pen 19, Callum Styles 23, Devante Cole 75) 3-0 Shrewsbury
Away Fixture: 13/02/2024 Shrewsbury (Nicky Cadden og 7) 1-1Barnsley (Herbie Kane pen 90)
Aggregate Score 4-1
Final Position: 20th – Burton Albion
Home Fixture: 16/09/2023 Barnsley (Devante Cole 21, 68) 2-0 Burton
Home Fixture: 01/04/2024 Burton (Joe Powell 37) 1-3 Barnsley (John McAtee 54, 64, Luca Connell 69)
Aggregate Score 5-1
Final Position: 21st – Cheltenham Town
Away Fixture: 02/09/2023 Cheltenham 0-2 Barnsley (Devante Cole 54, Max Watters 90)
Home Fixture: 16/03/2024 Barnsley 0-0 Cheltenham
Aggregate Score 2-0
Final Position: 22nd – Fleetwood Town
Home Fixture: 28/10/2023Barnsley (Devante Cole 7, Corey O’Keeffe 88) 2-2 Fleetwood (Junior Quitrna 3, 34)
Away Fixture: 17/02/2024 Fleetwood (Bosun Lawal 32) 1-2 Barnsley (Sam Cosgrove 23, Herbie Kane 59)
Aggregate Score 4-3
Final Position: 23rd – Port Vale
Home Fixture: 05/08/2023 Barnsley (Devante Cole 23, 47, 53, Dan Jones og 45, Liam Kitching 60, Jon Russell 64, Andy Dalles 90) 7-0 Port Vale
Away Fixture: 26/12/2023 Port Vale (Ethan Chislett 72, Jack Shorrock 90) 2-3 Barnsley (Adam Phillips 17, John McAtee 32, 37)
Aggregate Score 10-2
Final Position: 24th – Carlisle United
Home Fixture: 16/01/2024 Barnsley (Devante Cole 58, Herbie Kane pen 86) 2-1 Carlisle (Luke Armstrong 7)
Away Fixture: 12/03/2024 Carlisle (Luke Armstrong 10, Daniel Butterworth 87) 2-3 Barnsley (Jordan Wiliams 33, John McAtee 49, Jon Russell 76)
Aggregate Score 5-3
Overall record v bottom half: W14 D7 L3 F49 A24 Points: 49